Skip Nav

Defending dissertation

What is a thesis defense?

❶Return to top of page.

Thesis defense rehearsal

Thoughts on continuous improvement: from TPS to XPS
Search form
Dissertation

If you got a written comment to your thesis from the committee you should have read it carefully and practiced a few responses to the obvious questions in it.

In any case, the most important advice is this one: This is the day to be humble. All research has weaknesses. Be confident about your choices and results, but agree that it could have be done better or differently. That will take you far.

Some questions deserve a few seconds thought. Write them down as soon as you hear that there are several questions bundled into one. Use examples if you have them. No one knows what you have seen and heard, hence you own the truth and can speak freely and in pictures.

Examples come with the additional benefit of being interesting for the audience. Finally, the PhD defense is not meant to be a walk in the park. The most usual one, which you can pull a few times and that will quickly end any difficult question is this one: If you need to buy yourself some time, and you know that you have treated the question somewhere in you thesis, you can lend this dry joke from me: But note; this last-resort-option can only be used once, so save it carefully.

Smile, have fun, enjoy YOUR day! I wish you the best of luck. Thank you very much for all of your advices! This was a great read! Thank you very much for the post. I am close to my defense. My advisor and most of my committee is very supportive of my work. However one member is creating nuisance over a published peer-reviewed journal part of my dissertation and essentially making comments in academically unprofessional tone? I need him to sign my dissertation. If you or someone can offer some thoughts on this ….

Congrats on beeing so close! My advise is to not bore the h.. My dissertation defence is on 15 December. Just curious if actually you were this calm before your defence took place. Their faces were showing satisfaction, follow up with great interest. This slideshow requires JavaScript. What does chess have to do with operations strategy? I love your post and it helped me a lot to be more self-confident during MY day: Congratulations on earning your degree: Glad you could find some help in the post.

Good luck on the 13th!! Enjoy the day and hope you are successful: You are helping me to develop a sense of fun! How often do the things that your experiment does come up in the real world?

What's involved in extending it? If it's easy to extend, why haven't you? If your example is a piece of a larger system, how realistic are your assumptions about input and output? The same kind of defense applies here as in the previous case, but now serious comparisons with previous systems are required.

Can your result do the same examples the previous results did, or can you make them do yours? Can you prove they couldn't do your examples? If you claim to be more efficient, what are you measuring? This is usually defended by a logical argument. It is usually very tough to do, even if the argument doesn't have to be formalized. Many students make the mistake of picking this kind of thesis to defend. It requires serious experimental evidence to defend, unless your real thesis is of the previous form, i.

Selected excerpts from protocols and surveys of your officemates are not psychological evidence, no matter how much they might have inspired your work. This is a reasonable thesis if process X is a serious contender. The defense would be an analysis of the limits of process X, i.

Defending a real thesis is hard. If you think you have a lot of theses, you probably just have a bunch of undefended claims. One good thesis, or two so-so theses, with adequate description and defense, is more than enough to fill up a dissertation. If you're bright, educated, and have worked hard on a topic for more than a year, you must have learned something no one else knew before. The first mistake that students make is to think that a thesis has to be grander than the theory of relativity.

A thesis should be new and interesting, but it doesn't have to change the foundations of all we believe and hold dear. Don't try to come up with a thesis first, and then investigate it. Start by exploring some task domain. Take some initial ideas and push them hard for a year or so. Now, stop and think about what you've done and what you've learned. Among your accomplishments and experience, there will be several good candidate theses.

Test it out on your advisor and other faculty members.

Narrow the focus

Main Topics

Privacy Policy

The dissertation defense is a significant milestone signaling closure on your graduate student career. The dissertation defense can be divided into three distinct components (Foss and Waters): the preparation, the defense, and follow-up.

Privacy FAQs

How to defend your PhD dissertation. A PhD defense is a serious ceremony. Yet, it can be one of the best days in your life. Here's how.

About Our Ads

Certainly, a masteral thesis is relatively more comprehensive in scope and normally defended in front of an examining panel or a committee. A custom dissertation is a research paper or a thesis usually done by a candidate to a doctoral degree. However, it has become customary for many institutions to refer to a dissertation as a doctoral thesis. You can battle this nervousness by showing up well-prepared. If you are, the thesis defense talk is just a formality. If you cannot obtain any thesis defense talks on video, make sure that you go to actual public thesis defense talks.

Cookie Info

Thesis defense rehearsal. When preparing to defend your thesis, familiarize yourself with the guidelines and requirements your department has put into place. Speak with your advisor to be sure that you know exactly what is expected of you. This entry was posted in Books, Higher Education, Leadership, relationships and tagged advice for defending your dissertation, advisor, advisor's job during the defense, committees, defense, dissertation.