There are those for the draft, and those against it. Each has its own argument for why or why not the American government has the constitutional right to force young men to fight in a war. These views have caused many different reactions since the draft was first used. The draft was first used in , during the Civil War. At the time, in was known as conscription. You could avoid conscription by paying a one-time fee of three hundred dollars, or you could hire a substitute to fight in your place.
The next time it was used was during World War I. It was started with the Selective Service Act of Under the act, all men between the ages of 21 and 30 had to register. These ages were later extended to include everyone between the ages of 18 and A person could be exempted from registering if they had dependant families, were disabled, or met other qualifications.
By the end of the war, 2. Men were first required to register during peacetime under the Selective Training and Service Act of This act said that a man could only be forced to serve for one. Once the country entered World War II, all men between the ages of 18 and 65 had to register, with all of those.
They could be required to serve for two years. When the Military Selective Service Act of was passed, the age to register was lowered to Another part of this act was that a person could defer service if they were still in school.
In , President Ford ended the draft due to the protests in America. In , however, Congress decided to pass an act requiring all men 18 to 25 to register.
In the case of a crisis, the draft could be reenacted and a lottery would be held to determine who would serve http: There are two different views on the draft.
The first is in favor of the government calling up its citizens to fight. The supporters of this view state that it is a very efficient way to make sure that our armed forces have enough men to fight a war.
The supporters say that the Selective Service is the only way that we would have had enough men to send during the World Wars, Korea, and Vietnam. They say that without these men who were forced to serve, we would have lost more of these wars other than Vietnam. According to these people and the government it is the right of a government to force its citizens to fight in defense of their country www.
On the other hand, there is the opinion that the government should not be able to call up its young males to fight. These people reacted in many ways. Some of them went to the Pentagon to burn their draft cards even though they could be arrested Holland Then there were those who when called up ran from the country.
When he was called up, he had just been accepted to graduate school. Soon before he was to report, he decided to run to Canada to escape the draft. He stayed just south of Canada for about a week. On his last day up near the border, the owner of the lodge he had been staying at took him in a boat and they crossed the Canadian border.
He was going to jump overboard to leave the United States when he realized that he would be a coward. Most people did not come the same realization as he did. Many, including Ali, were looked at as cowards.
The war was bad, I ended up right. I'm still the winner. These people were really stood up for what America was for by standing for what they believed in even though it was not what everyone wanted them to do http: The Selective service has been brought under much scrutiny since it was first used more than one hundred and fifty years ago. Many men have died in wars that they did not even want to fight in. He continues "I should've stepped in; fourth grade is no excuse. This quote shows that the young soldiers are not really brave, they are just confused about what bravery is.
They went to war not because they supported it or wanted to show themselves in the field — they went because they were afraid not to. What they experience is a simple fear and shame. In chapter six two young soldiers by names Strunk and Jensen think that life would not be worth living if they get injured. For them the death and disgrace would be to be crippled on in wheelchairs. Though, the course of the war is unpredictable and Strunk loses part of his leg.
He is terrified, and realizes that primarily he wants to live, with two full legs or even one and a half. He realizes how childish he was, he understands that what he thought was brave is simply absurd, the main important thing is to live. The effect the war has on a person is seen in the first chapter when before the reader appears a situation of a young solider dying and his fellow-fighters mourning for him.
When Jimmy Cross understood that Ted Lavender was dead, and that he could have prevented it, his perception of life changed. Before, what he could think about was only his girlfriend Martha. He was a loving boyfriend before he was a soldier. Later he realized that the only thing that cannot be changed in this world is death. This occurrence made him apprehend his duties as a soldier and all what seemed important then became dull. In chapter three we see that the lack of a purpose sometimes drives the men crazy.
The soldiers feel that there is no morality to what they are doing. Their wartime life seems eternal, boring, boring and frighteningly useless. In chapter five Dave Jensen becomes unable to tell what is right and what is wrong. In chapter nine we realize how an innocent young girl Mary Anne Bell, who was only in Vietnam a few months, lost herself in the country.
This demonstrates that he considers that it would be impossible for someone to express an objective opinion concerning warfare as long as the respective individual experienced it directly.
While one might be inclined to believe that the writer is not very similar to Tim's character in the book due to the fictional elements in the collection of stories, the reality is that they are actually very similar. O'Brien's affinity for reading played an important role in shaping his character as a young man and in influencing him to want to become a writer later in his life.
The collection practically provides readers with the chance to gain a more complex understanding of war as a result of looking at it from the perspective of individuals who actually experienced it. O'Brien brought together a series of elements present in his earlier works in an attempt to paint a vivid picture of warfare.
While there are a series of texts related to warfare and to how people need to get actively involved in denouncing this activity, O'Brien's collection of stories is easily distinguishable from the rest. This writer actually managed to provide a somewhat comic outlook concerning subjects that are serious. This was made possible by the fact that he was focused on detaching himself from the ordinary and getting actively engaged in showing that warfare is practically part of life and part of what humanity is.
The collection's title is actually essential in having readers understand the message that O'Brien wants to put across. Although he experienced warfare firsthand and although he saw the suffering it provoked, he did not hesitate to use a rather trivial title for his stories.
The fact that he actually goes through with describing the things that he and his colleagues were carrying can actually influence some readers in thinking that the writer thinks about physical suffering resulting from carrying heavy objects as one of the most important problems associated with warfare.
O'Brien apparently thinks of short stories as being an end themselves and as providing readers with the opportunity to see the bigger picture by being familiarized with characters and situations they see in several stories. This strategy is especially effective, as "the inter-woven stories some of which are more like commentaries on stories than actual stories collectively form a dramatic and discursive novel Society for the Study of the Short Story.
The collection enabled O'Brien to express a series of intense topics and to provide information concerning how fiction can be efficient in accompanying realistic stories. One of the principal ideas in O'Brien's short story is related to how most individuals who interact with war end up wanting to run from it. It is very probable that he uses writing as a method to run from his past, as even though he recollects his memories as he writes, he uses humor in an attempt to disguise his feelings.
It virtually seems that he is successful as he introduces fiction with the purpose of making events he experienced even more interesting than they are. One might actually tend to believe that his war experiences were tedious and that he experienced little to no actual combat when considering the way he uses fiction. I was twenty-one years old. Young, yes, and politically naive, but even so the American war in Vietnam seemed to me wrong.
Paper Masters Custom Research Papers on Tim O'Brien's "The Things They Carried" Paper Masters writes custom research papers on Tim O'Brien's "The Things They Carried" and look at an example of how to order an annotated bibliography.
- The Things They Carried In , Tim O'Brien released his second novel about Vietnam, and in the late Sunday edition of the New York Times in March, Robert Harris, editor of .
In order to keep their sanity and their hope, they carried with them pieces of the life they left behind. In The Things They Carried, the soldiers of Lt. Cross’s platoon are told to carry with them pieces of home. For example, Lieutenant Jimmy Cross carried with him . The Things They Carried analysis paper Themes in The Things They Carried “In a story, which is a kind of dreaming, the dead sometimes smile and sit up and return to the world,” writes Tim O’Brien in his novel The Things They Carried (). Throughout the story, O’Brien discusses themes such as death, the loss of innocence, and truth.
Short Story an Analysis of Tim O'Brien's the Things They Carried View Paper . Tim O'Brien's "The Things They Carried" The Things They Carried is an emotional narrative about several American soldiers serving together in the Vietnam War. The Things They Carried Introduction When speaking of western history in terms of existence of the human species, the events carried in the acts of war remain totemic in nature spanning through the entire landscape. There are physical as well as mental borders.